Off the Shelf: A quirky pandemic love story that hits close to home

Hafner portrays the toll forced isolation can take on the human psyche within the context of the COVID-19 pandemic

I’ve written before about how difficult it is for me to read novels in which the COVID-19 pandemic plays a central theme. The virus doesn’t feel far enough in the past to have already become a subgenre of historical fiction, and trying to stay focused on books about the pandemic often ends with me staring into space, lost in my own memories.

When I started reading Katie Hafner’s “The Boys,” I didn’t know that it was about the COVID-19 pandemic. (Nor did I know I would contract COVID-19 a week later, but that’s beside the point.) The book lured me in with a bright pastel cover and a mysterious summary, and I took the bait.

Hafner is a former staff writer at The New York Times, where she wrote about health care and technology for 10 years and is now a frequent contributor. “The Boys,” is her first novel, and it maybe makes sense that those topics are motifs throughout.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

“The Boys,” follows the reclusive Ethan Fawcett, who falls in love with outgoing Barb. As their relationship progresses, Ethan’s childhood trauma causes problems as they look to begin a family.

It’s difficult to summarize the plot of “The Boys” without giving away some of the details or plot points that make it such a compelling read. Ethan and Barb are both lovable protagonists who feel so real, it’s like you’ve met them before. The love story is a charming tale of introvert-meets-extrovert, in which their differences complement each other and nurture their comfortable life founded on mutual respect.

Underlying that story, though, is a darker tone stemming from Ethan’s loss of his parents as a child. The incident leaves him with a fear of parenthood that creates wrinkles in their marriage and prompts Barb to bring home two boys — yes, the boys — as a sort-of parenting trial run. Ethan’s bond with the boys is immediate and runs deep — deeper than Barb’s, in a way that drives the couple apart.

What feels as true-to-life as the characters is the way Hafner portrays the toll forced isolation can take on the human psyche within the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. In my experience, stories about the COVID-19 pandemic play up the same themes and imagery associated with other depictions of pandemics in media: tired doctors, sick loved ones, global panic.

All of those, of course, were elements of the COVID-19 pandemic. What resonated with me about “The Boys,” though, was Hafner’s depiction of how forced isolation — quarantine and social distancing — exacerbated Ethan’s already severe introversion. His character pushes the concept to its limit, pulling at the loose thread of the idea until the whole sweater has unraveled.

His story is a sympathetic one. “The Boys” is a novel without an antagonist. As in life, it’s not always easy to identify what is driving the conflict; people have good days and bad days, and don’t always behave like you expect them to.

“The Boys,” is not the first book to dramatize the COVID-19 pandemic, and it certainly won’t be the last. As authors duke it out for their own slice of that niche literary canon, I think “The Boys” will stand out as an eccentric and endearing story of human connection as essential

“The Boys,” was published in 2022 by Spiegel & Grau.

Reach reporter Ashlyn O’Hara at ashlyn.ohara@peninsulaclarion.com.

Off the Shelf is a bimonthly literature column written by the staff of the Peninsula Clarion.

"The Boys" by Katie Hafner. (Photo via Amazon)
Tags: ,